St Louis Cardinals baseball:

C- Walker Cooper / Tim McCarver
1B- Albert Pujols
2B- Rogers Hornsby
3B- Scott Rolen / Ken Boyer
SS- Ozzie Smith
OF- Lou Brock
OF- Stan Musial
OF- Enos "Country" Slaughter
UT- Frankie Frisch
UT- Joe "Ducky" Medwick
UT- Mark McGwire
UT- Whitey Kurowski
UT- Johnny "Pepper" Martin
UT- Ted Simmons
SP- Bob Gibson
SP- Dizzy Dean
SP- Steve Carlton
SP- Bob Forsch
SP- Chris Carpenter
RP- Dennis Eckersley
RP- Lee Smith
RP- Jason Isringhausen
RP- Bruce Sutter

I believe they match-up well with any othe MLB all time team out there.